11/1/2009 4:32 AM
Email this article Print this article  

A radical change city's only hope

Observer-Reporter

This article has been read 337 times.

Regardless of who wins election to Washington City Council this week, the speed and direction in which the city is headed will not be altered. It is now alarmingly apparent that the city is careening down the road to financial ruin, barring some radical change.

Consider the city's pension obligations. In addition to the $1.2 million annual payment that must be made on the bond issue to support the combined pension fund, the city owes at least another $753,000 to keep it funded. That's the minimum amount this year, but it would be wiser to pay $1.6 million now than to ensure much higher payments in years to come. So, where does a city with a declining tax base, declining population and zero growth come up with, say, $2.8 million a year for pensions? Taxation is its only resort, and the more businesses and residents are taxed, the more likely they are to pick up and leave. Tax them enough and they'll have no choice.

How did Washington get into such a predicament? It's complicated. Who's to blame? That's even more complicated, but you might start with plastic.

Fifty years ago, everything from ketchup to shampoo came in a glass container. A lot of the glass was made here. At the peak of the glass industry, Washington had 28,000 residents, many of them employed in local glass factories and spending their money in stores downtown. The city was well able to afford large police and fire departments.




Rate This Story:
1 the lowest - 5 the highest
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Current rating:
Then came plastic containers: cheaper and easier to make and ship. One by one, the glass factories closed. Now, the city has just 15,000 residents and its commercial district has nearly vanished. But the police and fire departments are still here, and the streets must still be maintained.

As prosperity waned, city government made poor decisions as it negotiated contracts with its unions. In 2006, for example, City Council approved a "20 and out" agreement with the fire department, then extended the contract to 2012. A firefighter, regardless of his age, could retire after 20 years of service at half pay. But that half was based on compensation distorted by overtime, so that some firefighters were receiving payment of more than their full salary, for the rest of their lives. And Council approved this despite an actuary's warning that the 20-and-out provision alone would add $540,000 in unfunded liability.

What can be done? The options aren't many and may be politically impossible. Municipal merger is the obvious solution. The city and its surrounding municipalities, which someday will face the same financial turmoil, would benefit greatly by combining police and fire services, as well as others like code enforcement, tax collection and street repair. But the prospects of that happening are almost nil. East Washington Borough, which already depends on the city's fire department, could have easily contracted with the city for police protection when the borough's chief retired recently. Instead, a new chief was hired to oversee 10 part-time officers.

Another option for the city might be a fire department that is part paid and part volunteer, operating on about half its current $2 million budget. This might seem like a radical change, but consider another possibility, and a more likely one if nothing is done: no police or fire protection in the city.

That's where the city is headed now. We hope that those elected to office and the people who put them there with their votes have the courage to acknowledge that reality.




Home



1 comments

The fire department : 11/2/2009
The firemen surely realize that their pension situation needs revamped. I hope city council tackles that pension problem as one of their priorities this coming year.


All comments will be reviewed by administrators and posted to their respective articles within 24 hours. Comments deemed inappropriate will not be posted.
Subject:
Body:
Poster:
captcha 4f82b0dab8c141c2b8af7683aac6b80e
Enter text seen above:








Marketplace
Classifieds
Jobs
Cars
Real Estate
Rate card
Photo Store
News
Local
Obituaries
Police Beat
Business
State
Nation
World
Communities
Washington County
Greene County
South Hills
Sports
Headlines
Blogs
Columns
Opinion
Editorials
Letters
Submit Letter
Blogs
Columns
Forum
Lifestyle
Entertainment
Engagements
Weddings
Anniversaries
Births
Calendar
Announcement Forms
Service
Subscribe
Temp. stop delivery
About Us
Contact Us
Terms of Service
Facebook | Twitter
Newsletter
This page is best viewed using Firefox.
Spreadfirefox Affiliate Button
© 2009 Observer Publishing Company. All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.