Cincinnati 2, New York Red Bulls 1
| Cincinnati | 2 | – | 2 |
| New York Red Bulls | 0 | – | 1 |
First Half_1, New York Red Bulls, Fernandez, 3 (penalty kick), 28th minute.
Second Half_2, Cincinnati, Acosta, 11 (penalty kick), 80th; 3, Cincinnati, Nwobodo, 2, 90th+3.
Goalies_Cincinnati, Roman Celentano, Alec Kann; New York Red Bulls, Carlos Miguel, Ryan Meara.
Yellow Cards_Ndam, New York Red Bulls, 3rd; Pinto, Cincinnati, 19th; Edelman, New York Red Bulls, 45th+1; Santos, Cincinnati, 62nd; Vanzeir, New York Red Bulls, 64th; Ordonez, Cincinnati, 71st.
Referee_Lukasz Szpala. Assistant Referees_Ian McKay, Brian Dunn, Jose Carlos Rivero. 4th Official_John Griggs.
Lineups
Cincinnati_Roman Celentano; Raymon Gaddis (Santiago Arias, 61st), Nick Hagglund, Yerson Mosquera, Alvas Powell; Luciano Acosta, Marco Angulo (Sergio Santos, 61st), Alvaro Barreal (Bret Halsey, 90th+5), Obinna Nwobodo, Malik Pinto (Junior Moreno, 46th); Arquimides Ordonez (Ben Stitz, 73rd).
New York Red Bulls_Carlos Miguel; Kyle Duncan, Hassan Ndam (Peter Stroud, 81st), Sean Nealis; Frankie Amaya, Daniel Edelman, Omir Fernandez, Luquinhas; Tom Barlow (Wikelman Carmona, 72nd), Cameron Harper (Matthew Nocita, 64th), Dante Vanzeir.