New York Red Bulls 1, Nashville 0
| New York Red Bulls | 1 | – | 1 |
| Nashville | 0 | – | 0 |
First Half_None.
Second Half_1, New York Red Bulls, Tolkin, 3 (penalty kick), 90th+4 minute.
Goalies_New York Red Bulls, Carlos Miguel, Ryan Meara; Nashville, Joe Willis, Elliot Panicco.
Yellow Cards_Reyes, New York Red Bulls, 39th; Amaya, New York Red Bulls, 45th+2; Picault, Nashville, 45th+3; Nealis, New York Red Bulls, 45th+6; Duncan, New York Red Bulls, 70th.
Referee_Lukasz Szpala. Assistant Referees_Corey Parker, Kyle Atkins, Ted Unkel. 4th Official_Malik Badawi.
Lineups
New York Red Bulls_Carlos Miguel; Kyle Duncan (Dylan Nealis, 86th), Sean Nealis, Andres Reyes, John Tolkin; Frankie Amaya (Dru Yearwood, 72nd), Daniel Edelman, Omir Fernandez (Cameron Harper, 56th), Luquinhas; Tom Barlow, Elias Manoel (Jorge Leguin Cabezas Hurtado, 87th).
Nashville_Joe Willis; Daniel Lovitz, Jack Maher, Shaq Moore, Walker Zimmerman; Sean Davis, Anibal Godoy, Randall Leal (Fafa Picault, 33rd), Hany Mukhtar, Alex Muyl (Jacob Shaffelburg, 77th); Sam Surridge (Teal Bunbury, 76th).