close

Now boarding: There has to be a better way

3 min read
article image -
Kristin Emery

It’s been almost a year since Southwest Airlines made the dramatic switch from allowing passengers to choose their own seat to assigning seats. This was a major adjustment for me since I fly that airline a lot and I hate sitting in the middle seat. I’m a window seat person while my husband prefers to sit on the aisle, so we have fallen into a pattern where we always have a stranger sitting between us. Sometimes, we luck out and the middle seat remains empty. We fly so much that we have some sort of status that lets us choose a regular seat for free now.

The new Southwest model assigns random seats at check-in to those who don’t pay for a certain seat ahead of time. That has somehow morphed into the random-seat people boarding the plane toward the end. I’ve watched the boarding process over and over and realize the middle-seat people having to climb past those already sitting in the aisle slows down the whole show and clogs up the aisle. Isn’t there a better way?

Apparently, I should become an astrophysicist because there is actually something called the Steffen Boarding Method (developed by an astrophysicist) that is mathematically the most efficient way to board a plane. And it’s the same way I always thought airlines should board passengers!

The Steffen Method eliminates aisle bottlenecks and reduces luggage-stowing delays by boarding window seats first, middle seats second and aisle seats last. This prevents people in the same row from blocking each other in the narrow aisle while putting bags in the overhead bin, and it’s been proven to cut boarding time in half. So why don’t airlines use it?

The answer is the same reason as so many other things in this world: money. Some experts argue that it is too logistically difficult to board with the Steffen Method and that it separates families and people who are traveling together during the boarding process.

I get it: You can’t board a parent first and have a child boarding separately in a different group. Still, I suspect the real reason airlines don’t even attempt to try this method is that they make more money boarding priority passengers first – This means first-class ticket-holders or those who gain early boarding access through credit card perks or flying a whole lot.

That brings me to another question: Why do people want to get on a plane first and just sit there longer? I’d be happy to jump into my seat as the last in line right before takeoff. But then you may not have any room left for your bag in the overhead bin. Don’t even get me started on that issue. Why is there not enough space in each row’s overhead bin for one bag from each passenger?

Maybe we can find an astrophysicist to solve that problem.

Kristin Emery can be reached at kristinemery1@yahoo.com.

Starting at /week.