Emails reveal discussions of ‘active investigation’ into Buchtan’s residency
About three weeks before the May 19 primary election, former Washington County GOP chairman Dave Ball emailed county Commissioner Nick Sherman inquiring about the status of the investigation he requested into state Senate candidate Al Buchtan’s residency.
During an April 23 county elections board meeting, Ball had formally requested a criminal investigation into Buchtan’s claims he lived in a Canonsburg apartment and not the Greene County home where his family resided.
The county elections board had just removed Buchtan from Washington County’s voter rolls after a state Commonwealth Court judge ruled in early April that the candidate truly resided at his family’s Cumberland Township home and not in Canonsburg. That court ruling allowed the candidate to remain in the Republican primary running against state Sen. Camera Bartolotta for the 46th State Senate District, but Ball claimed it illustrated that Buchtan had committed voter fraud since he had voted in Canonsburg in the previous November’s off-year election.
“I recognize that these are serious requests that implicate the rights of a candidate whose status is actively contested. I do not take them lightly,” Ball wrote in his May 1 email to Sherman while also citing election code. “Where suspicious circumstances exist and apparent violations are evidence, the (Elections) Board must act. The record here leaves no room for doubt that they do.”
A few days later, Ball sent a follow-up email to Sherman asking for an “update on the status of this investigation” because “time is of the essence in this matter.”
Sherman emailed Ball on May 7 notifying him that the elections board had turned over his request to District Attorney Jason Walsh, who then forwarded it to the state Attorney General’s office for review since the county prosecutor had publicly pledged his support for Bartolotta in the campaign.
“At this time, it is now considered an active investigation with the AG’s office and we cannot make any further comment,” Sherman wrote in his email to Ball.
During that time, the Senate Republican Caucus Committee began sending political mailers and text messages to voters that Buchtan was under “active criminal investigation” for voter fraud, citing a “Washington County Election Official Email” as its source. It’s not known if Sherman’s email or another message is the source for the SRCC’s mailers and messages.
Meanwhile, the state Attorney General’s office did not notify Walsh that it had accepted the case to investigate Buchtan until May 15, just four days before the primary election. The state Attorney General’s office messaged Walsh on Aug. 13 that it had “investigated this matter” and ultimately “declined to file or otherwise pursue any criminal charges” against Buchtan.
The correspondence between Ball and Sherman was released Monday as part of an ongoing open records request by the Observer-Reporter and Herald-Standard newspapers asking for information about who notified the SRCC about the investigation.
Reached for comment Friday, Ball denied forwarding Sherman’s email to the SRCC or being in contact with political operatives in Harrisburg ahead of the primary in which he supported Bartolotta’s re-election.
“No, I didn’t. That was just information to me,” Ball said. “I don’t really know (who contacted SRCC) because I didn’t have anything to do with it.”
Sherman said Friday he merely responded to Ball’s messages asking him to refer the matter to prosecutors, which the elections board did.
“A constituent of mine accused someone of criminal wrong-doing,” Sherman said. “Per the policies and procedures of Washington County, any time someone calls my office about criminal wrong-doing, we turn it over to the district attorney’s office, because they are the ones that pursued criminal investigations. And that’s what I did.”
He declined further comment because he and fellow Republican Commissioner Electra Janis – both of whom supported Bartolotta in the primary – are being sued in federal court by Buchtan over claims they used their positions to tip the election in favor of the incumbent. Bartolotta defeated Buchtan by a narrow 53.5-to-46.5% margin in the primary, and then won re-election to her fourth term in office by defeating independent candidate Jodi Borello on Nov. 3.
The SRCC did not respond to an email Friday asking the political organization to comment on who sent it the information that Buchtan was under “active criminal investigation” before it was publicly known.
The newspapers filed the open records request on July 6 after Buchtan filed his federal lawsuit. The county failed to respond timely after asking for a 30-day delay, prompting the newspapers to appeal to the state’s Office of Open Records, which ordered Washington County officials on Oct. 30 to continue searching for an email citing an “active investigation” into Buchtan, giving them until Monday to respond with more documents.