close

A look at the vice-presidential candidates

By Gary Stout 5 min read

“The vice presidency is not worth a bucket of warm spit.” – John Nance Garner

There has long been disagreement among political scientists whether vice-presidential candidates make a difference in presidential elections. The much-repeated quote about the vice presidency from John Nance Garner, Franklin Roosevelt’s first vice president, sums up the traditional view that voters pay little attention to the second person on a national ticket.

In recent elections, this opinion has changed. For example, there is strong evidence that Sarah Palin damaged John McCain in 2008 and that Joe Biden garnered important votes for Barack Obama in the same election.

The definitive book on the subject is the 2020 book “Do Running Mates Matter? The Influence of Vice-Presidential Candidates in Presidential Elections” by Christopher Devine and Kyle Kopko. The authors concluded that a running mate who is experienced and well-qualified can improve the perception of the presidential candidate, capture some votes, and make a difference.

The following commentary provides background and opinion on each of the vice-presidential candidates in the upcoming election: Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, a Democrat, and Ohio Republican U.S. Sen. JD Vance. I gained some insights from those who live in the home state of each candidate and relied on the excellent deep-dive reports published by Politico on each candidate’s history.

Tim Walz. Dana Ferguson from Minnesota Public Radio reports that Walz “was able to pass a balanced budget in the state with a Senate Republican majority and a House Democratic majority.” In 2023 he passed “a child tax credit, legal protections for abortions, along with new protections for workers and for voters.”

I spoke with my cousin, Noel Bye, who lives in Minneapolis, and was happy to see Walz chosen to join Kamala Harris on the Democrat’s ticket. He said, “Walz has been an amazing governor and we are sorry to lose him. He has been able to reach across the aisle and accomplish many things, including a free breakfast and lunch program for schools. He has actually worked for a living and understands the struggles the middle class faces every day.”

The article from Politico, “55 things to know about Tim Walz,” provides basic information. Walz was raised in Butte, Neb., a town of about 400 people. He enlisted in the Army National Guard at age 17. After college, he learned to speak Mandarin and traveled to China with a government-sanctioned group to teach in Chinese high schools. Walz served in the Army for 24 years and retired as a sergeant major.

In Minnesota, Walz taught geography and coached high school football. He was first elected to Congress in 2006 and re-elected five times in a mostly rural, conservative section of the state. In Congress, Walz was named the ranking member on the House Committee on Veterans Affairs. He often worked with Republicans to sponsor and pass legislation.

Walz is an avid hunter who is graded “F” by the National Rifle Association because of his forward-looking positions on gun control. In 2018, he ran for Governor of Minnesota and defeated his Republican opponent by 11 points. Walz was chosen to chair the Democratic Governors Association, in 2023.

Walz has a theory that candidates endorsed by former President Donald Trump are weird, and voters are turned off by their radical positions.

JD Vance. In Ohio, state Attorney General Dave Yost has called Vance “a patriot and fighter for Ohio’s forgotten middle class.” A close friend from Columbus, Ohio, Michele Wyatt, disagrees. She told me, “Vance’s move to Ohio was done to support his political aspirations. I think it is dangerous to have someone as ideologically fluid, with minimal experience, questionable ties, and unclear motivations hold the position of second-in-command.”

Returning to Politico, the article “55 things to know about JD Vance,” is a similar in-depth study of Vance’s background. Vance grew up in a working-class family in post-industrial Ohio. He describes himself as a descendant of “hillbilly royalty” and was raised primarily by his grandparents. Vance wrote a bestselling memoir, “Hillbilly Elegy,” about his early years in Jackson, Ky., and Middleton, Ohio.

During the 2016 election, Vance emerged as a vocal critic of Trump. In a TV interview, he stated “I am a Never Trump guy” and tweeted “My god, what an idiot.'” However, during Trump’s years as president, Vance came to support his policies. He voted for Trump in 2020.

After graduating from Yale Law School, Vance joined a venture capital firm run by the Silicon Valley Republican Peter Thiel. In 2022, Vance ran for and won the Ohio Senate seat, his first public office. He was endorsed by Trump and received over $10 million in donations from his employer.

During his brief time in the Senate, Vance has embraced the New Right and has attempted to push the Republican Party in a more populist, nationalist, and culturally conservative direction. He is a leading critic of American support for Ukraine and has called the Democratic border policy “a deliberate strategy to kill Republican voters with fentanyl.”

In recent polls, Walz is clearly viewed as more experienced and more likable than Vance. Vance has assumed the role of attack dog and Walz as a moderate Midwesterner. However, there is no evidence that either vice-presidential candidate will move the needle with Republicans or Democrats. Because more independents have an unfavorable view of Vance, like Palin in 2008, he could hurt the Trump ticket in the critical battleground states.

Gary Stout is a Washington attorney.

CUSTOMER LOGIN

If you have an account and are registered for online access, sign in with your email address and password below.

NEW CUSTOMERS/UNREGISTERED ACCOUNTS

Never been a subscriber and want to subscribe, click the Subscribe button below.

Starting at $3.75/week.

Subscribe Today