2017 Best of the Best Insurance Agencies in Washington and Greene Counties

Finding the right insurance agency can be a difficult task. Once you develop a knowledge of your insurance needs, there is a still a great deal to consider.
One of the best tools in finding a good insurance agency match is referrals from family, friends and neighbors. Our region is lucky to have numerous insurance agencies with deep commitments to the communities they serve.
But don’t take our word for it.
In 2017, the Observer-Reporter introduced the Best of the Best Awards to celebrate the best businesses, organizations, people and more that the residents of Washington and Greene counties thought deserved the distinction of best in their respective category.
The response from the community and nominees was overwhelming. More than 400,000 votes were captured from 11,000 unique voters, validating the vitality of the communities that comprise the Observer-Reporter’s coverage area.
One of our most popular categories was Best Insurance Agency. Here’s what our readers came up with.
Day Insurance Agency, Inc.
The Day Insurance Agency has been providing Washington and the greater Pittsburgh area with the best insurance rates since 1974. Their respected tradition of friendly, customer-oriented service has helped them become Washington’s major insurance agency with over 5000 local clients.
- Address:329 E. Maiden Street, Washington
- Website: dayinsurance.com
Bob Hollick State Farm Insurance
With a combined 90 years in the insurance business, the Bob Hollick team is dedicated to helping individuals manage the risks of everyday life.
- Address: 30 S. Main Street, Washington
- Website: bobhollick.com
Proudfit Insurance Agency
Proudfit Insurance delivers more than traditional insurance. The Proudfit team helps people understand their risks in a broader, more effective way so they can make better decisions.
- Address: 470 Johnson Road, Washington
- Website: proudfitinsurance.com
Anthony Bottino Allstate Insurance
Anthony Bottino is committed to helping his clients protect what’s important and providing an outstanding level of service.
- Address: 4686 PA – 51, Rostraver
- Website: agents.allstate.com/anthony-bottino-rostraver-township-pa.html
Janine Butterfield State Farm Insurance
Janine Butterfield is committed to helping individuals manage the risks of everyday life, recover from the unexpected and realize their dreams.
- Address: 442 McMurray Road, Bethel Park
- Website: janinebutterfield.com
Megan Chicone State Farm Insurance
As a third generation State Farm agent, Megan Chicone and her team are dedicated to helping their policyholders manage the risks of everyday life.
- Address: 807 E. McMurray Road, Venetia
- Website: meganchicone.com
Mike Williamson Farmers Insurance
Mike Williamson is dedicated to helping customers identify the insurance coverage that best fits their needs.
- Address: 214 W. Main Street, Monongahela
- Website: agents.farmers.com/pa/monongahela/michael-williamson
Disagree? Our 2018 Best of Best nominations begin Monday, July 23. Stay tuned!